Let's Talk Dogs...

lovely1m

lovely1m

Active member
After the whole cat allergy thing, we are now considering a dog. We've never had a dog before and I do not know much about them. We are hoping for something that is small, doesn't shed much, will play with my son, but also be chill, I am not a fan of dogs that jump all over people and are overly excitable. So tell me about your dogs and why you think that breed is good. Or tell me what you think would be best for us. Thanks!
 
I know poodles don't shed and they are very smart. I personally have a LONG HAIRED sheds everywhere dog, so not much help.
 
We have had german shepherd mixes, a golden retriever, and, currently, a yorkie-poo (yorkie-poodle mix). As much as I LOOOOOOOOOVED our Golden, he shed EVERYWHERE. And he was so big (100+ pounds) that he kind of outgrew our tiny house. We ended up giving him to a doctor couple who had no kids at home, so he was SO much happier.

Our Yorkie-Poo is PERFECT. He doesn't shed. He's about 13#, a total lap dog. He's super smart & learns quickly.

carth-web.jpg
 
Well....
My dog
  • is overly excitable
  • jumps on people
  • is large
  • sheds a lot

But she sure is great. :D She's a golden retriever.
 
Just be sure you absolutely know what you are getting into if you've never had a dog before. They are sooooo much different than a cat. I'm STILL second-guessing our decision to get a dog 7 months ago. I kind of want my life back.
 
I will say this.
My parents always started with puppies, and while puppies ARE cute, they are sooooo much work. John and I now always go with rescue dogs. We got Scarlet through a rescue group (http://www.magrr.org/) and it worked great for us. Scarlet had been given to them - as opposed to abandoned - when her previous owners decided that she didn't fit their lifestyle. She was already housebroken and had semi-learned some doggy manners. As first time dog owners I highly recommend trying to find an older dog that has already been taught his/her doggy manners and is housebroken.
 
maryinaz said:
Just be sure you absolutely know what you are getting into if you've never had a dog before. They are sooooo much different than a cat. I'm STILL second-guessing our decision to get a dog 7 months ago. I kind of want my life back.
Click to expand...

yes...a few years ago DH bought a baby bassett hound on a whim..he was adorable and cute and I thought we'd just deal with it. and then he grew and grew until he was about 80 lbs, smelled like a hound and proceeded to eat literally my house...when he started chewing on the white posts on my front porch I told DH it was either the dog or me lol

So we found him a good home (and still see him often) and then spent 2 years researching and looking for the perfect dog for us. We ended up adopting a 2 year old shitzu mix and he is the BEST dog. So calm and loving with our kids...doesn't bark too much, was already house trained which was a HUGE PLUS. Perfect size..not too big or too small. Grooming is fairly easy...all things I wanted. He just transitioned right into our family like he'd always been there...but like I said we took a LOT of time deciding what we wanted.

And I may never get a puppy again..having one already trained and past that chew everything up puppy stage was awesome.
 
Miniature or a larger toy poodle. This is why:

1. Soft medium-length hair that doesn't shed very much
2. Love being cuddled, sitting on your lap, don't need much in the way of exercise
3. Very smart (stay away from the frequently inbred toy & teacup variety, they are not as smart)
4. Easy to house train, obedience train
5. Good with kids
6. Generally healthy dogs

I will caution you to stay away from the -oodle trend. Just because something is mixed with a poodle doesn't automatically give it the poodle's great traits. A great example of this is my in-laws maltipoo who is one of the most annoying dogs I've ever known (and I love dogs). Bad with the kids, health problems, not non-allergenic (I'm allergic to her), barks constantly, piddles when she's excited. All traits associated with the over-bred Maltese. ;)

ETA: Just read Kristin's post about her sweet Yorkie-poo. I will say that there are good -poodle dogs out there, but the thing is... you really don't know for sure until they're older.
 
Last edited:
maryinaz said:
Just be sure you absolutely know what you are getting into if you've never had a dog before. They are sooooo much different than a cat. I'm STILL second-guessing our decision to get a dog 7 months ago. I kind of want my life back.
Click to expand...

We've only had fish and reptiles! We know nothing about pets in general. I have always said a dog is like another child and I only want one child, but I grew up with no pets and I do not want that for my son especially as an only a child. A cat had seemed perfect, but that's a no go now. Gerbils and such kinda weird me out. I like to look at them at the store, but could never touch one. Birds are too loud and I could never grab one of those either.
 
Last edited:
I really want to get one that is like a year from a rescue for all the reasons you mentioned, but then I think there's normally a reason dogs are given away and its normally cause they have some sort of issue. So I wonder then.
 
lovely1m said:
I really want to get one that is like a year from a rescue for all the reasons you mentioned, but then I think there's normally a reason dogs are given away and its normally cause they have some sort of issue. So I wonder then.
Click to expand...

Yeah sometimes, but then our dog's owners were moving and couldn't take him with them so there are cases like that also. And a lot of times it's just people getting dogs and not realizing how big a commitment they are and just taking them to shelters because of that. I'd definitely look into your local shelters...I know ours was really great about contacting us when they had dogs come in that were similar to what we were looking for..and the people who work there can usually give you good ideas of the dogs personalities etc.
 
Not all animals given to rescues are for behavioral issues. Sometimes it's the family moves and can't take the pet with, or a child is allergic and can't handle it, or something has come up.
 
We did get a puppy because yes, we all wanted a cute little puppy! :blink: And basically he is a good dog, and he was easy to house-break and crate-train. But it has been a TON of work. And he IS chewing up a lot of things but our trainer (we went through 2 training sessions 6-weeks each) said puppies teeth until 10 months. He's 9 months old now, so we shall see.

I, of course, am the main caretaker of him because I work at home and am with him all day. My boys lovelovelovelove him, but except for being the pooper-scoopers (which I refused to do from the start, although I am the vomit-cleaner), they don't do as much for/with him as I was hoping.

And like you Mari, I did this for my children. I did not want to hear "we were never allowed to have a dog" from my boys when they were all adults and on their own. Ours is an Aussie/Rottie mix of some kind from a shelter, so he IS a very active dog, but the boys wanted this type of dog.

If I had to do it over again, I would probably go for an older dog. You can find dogs in shelters that are great dogs.
 
lovely1m said:
I really want to get one that is like a year from a rescue for all the reasons you mentioned, but then I think there's normally a reason dogs are given away and its normally cause they have some sort of issue. So I wonder then.
Click to expand...

Well in defense of the dogs, I'd say a lot of times the owner is the issue, not the dog. Either their family circumstances changed or they weren't realistic about the amount of work the dog would be or do enough research to make sure that breed would be a good fit for their family. I think as long as you do your research and are honest about how much of a commitment it'll be, you'd be fine.

I don't know if this is an option in your area, but some breed rescues will let you be a dog foster parent while the dogs are waiting to be adopted. I don't know what the requirements are but it might be a good way to test the waters before making a full commitment. My sister & her boyfriend have been doing it for cats and it seems like it's been a good way to learn what life with a pet would be like without a long term commitment. Of course, you may fall in love with them and then have to give them up but it could be something to look into.
 
Its totally the owners fault most of the time, but what bad habits did they teach the dog in that time period. I looked at the local shelters some here and emailed them. They look good and we are in no rush so can wait a long time. I would much rather give a dog a home that needs it then pay hundreds for a puppy from a store.
 
If you are able to often times the shelters will take your name/interest for the type of dog you are interested in. :)

If we ever get a dog (which i can't really see happening) I'd go that route.. because at least you are able to see the personality etc and know for the most part the type of dog.. with a puppy you really have no clue!

I don't think I could do a puppy.. i'm done with babies.. and anything else that isn't potty trained or doesn't sleep through the night *lol*
 
We got a llhasa apso from the shelter many years ago. She was the homeliest looking dog there but I tend to lean toward the little uglies because my heart breaks and I'm afraid no one will want them. The shelter thought she was a breeder dog for a backyard breeder - she had had so many litters that her little teets never went back to their normal size. They think she had so many litters and they were done with her and someone dumped her. :-( She had no socialization skills and was not the smartest dog you've ever seen by far. BUT....what she lacked in those areas, she totally made up for in love and devotion and was the best. dog. ever. I think she totally knew that she was saved and appreciated every minute of her 7 years with us. I say go shelter all the way!!!

Another shelter thing...I truly believe that YOUR dog will call you. When I found Maggie, I went to the shelter almost every day (high turnover) for a few weeks I think and knew that when I found my dog, she would call to me. Many days I left alone but I was right..I waited...and she called me.
 
Stay away from bull dogs. We had one. She was so STRONG she knocked over my HUGE leather couch and destroyed my house.
 
Does that include French bull dogs, Kjersti? I saw a mix dog that was so stinky cute that was 1/2 French bulldog. I for sure do not want one that will destroy my house.
 
Ok I'm fresh into this topic as I bought a border collie pup 4 weeks ago, DH didn't want one but DD did, we both grew up with dogs and I wanted the enjoyment my dog gave me growing up I wanted that for DD.

I knew it would be hard work but oh my days I never knew it would be this hard. Max is 14weeks and is the most adorable little fluffy thing, he doesn't chew at all, he plays lovely and has a lovely temperament, but he just isn't getting the whole wee and poop outside, I have lost count the amount of wee & poop I have cleaned up off my floor. I have spend a couple of days just in tears wondering if I made the right decision on getting a puppy. I'm in the stage of crate training him now and hoping this works cause I don't know what else I can do.

I would defiantly consider an older dog if you don't want to have to go through housebreaking a puppy
 
I have a bull terrier. She's amazing but is white and sheds a lot twice a year. She is big and strong but she's never destroyed anything because of it.

I had a chihuahua who died last year and she was evil and tried to bite people and chewed anything she could! I'd never have another small dog.
 
I'm not a fan of Chihuahua's either! Especially for kids... They are snippy and so fragile. My SIL has one and it broke its leg jumping off the bed. :p
 
Kjersti said:
Stay away from bull dogs. We had one. She was so STRONG she knocked over my HUGE leather couch and destroyed my house.
Click to expand...

That was another problem with the bassett hound...he was so strong and heavy that...he wanted to play with the kids but they were so small he'd just knock them down. I was afraid he'd hurt them. AND when he'd jump up on you he was as tall as you b/c he was so long lol
 
I think one of the best things you can do before getting a dog is to research breeds like crazy... pick up a book like this one from the library and whittle it down to the breeds that are best suited to your lifestyle. :)

Based on your preferences:
small
doesn't shed much
playful
but also be chill
not overly excitable

I would definitely say that although they are small, a terrier is probably not for you. They are feisty & excitable, tend to bark a lot, and can be snippy with kids. My friends have an Italian Greyhound and they love him. He's a small, cute, quirky dog. I have never heard him bark and he never never jumps up on people. He's great with their son and fun to play frisbee & catch with. I know there are rescue's for them where you can foster one or adopt.
 
Ohh! You should get a dog like my mom has. I've grown up around these dang things, but for the life of me I can't remember what they're called. This is a serious "duh" moment going on for me. It's the Lady and the Tramp dog. lol
Hers are a little high maintenance, but not overly so, and that could just be because they are hers. They can be fun and playful, but they have no problem just chilling and snuggling. They don't shed and are medium sized. They CAN develop health problems if they aren't properly cared for and there is a chance for congestive heart failure, but out of the 5 she's had only one ever got it and she was lazy and overweight, and even then she lived to be about 16.
 
MommaTrish said:
Ohh! You should get a dog like my mom has. I've grown up around these dang things, but for the life of me I can't remember what they're called. This is a serious "duh" moment going on for me. It's the Lady and the Tramp dog. lol
Hers are a little high maintenance, but not overly so, and that could just be because they are hers. They can be fun and playful, but they have no problem just chilling and snuggling. They don't shed and are medium sized. They CAN develop health problems if they aren't properly cared for and there is a chance for congestive heart failure, but out of the 5 she's had only one ever got it and she was lazy and overweight, and even then she lived to be about 16.
Click to expand...

Cocker Spaniel? My aunt has one, Missy. Sweet dog. They can be prone to in-breeding (and the weight/heart problems you mentioned) and have piddle problems, but everyone I know that has one loves them to death. They have great personalities.
 
Yes because of the inbreeding it's really important that you either go through a rescue group just for cocker spaniels or you go through a very reputable breeder.
 
Oh gosh... LOL. I posted waaaay after you. That's what I get for taking almost an hour to reply to a thread. :o
 
We just lost our cocker after 13 years last spring. He was a sweet dog...he didn't like kids too much but he tolerated them. I think it's b/c I got him as a puppy before we got married so for a while he was used to being the baby. You have to groom them a lot b/c their hair tends to mat very easily if you don't but he was a very sweet tempered dog. Our biggest problem with him was that he loved to dig holes in the yard.
 
FWIW, we have German Shepherds...one is 17 months and the other is a pup we got 2 weeks ago. She's 14 weeks. They are amazing, smart dogs but they are bigger and they do shed. They also need quite a lot of exercise. The puppy does chew a lot, but we make sure to keep large bones around for her so whenever we catch her with something she shouldn't have, we trade it out for the bone...she's catching on. They're also very quick to learn right from wrong. We put our 1st through a one-month training course and found it invaluable and we'll be doing the same with the puppy as soon as she's old enough.

Before we got the new puppy, we tried rescuing a small dog from a shelter and that didn't turn out so well...he was a biter. We had to take him back and I swore I'd never do that again. I like the idea of giving an abandoned pet a good home, but with kids, it scares me to death not knowing exactly what you're getting. For me, the amount of work a puppy takes is worth it to be able to train them ourselves and establish from the start who the bosses are.

Good luck with your decision!!
 
German Shepherds are actually my favorite breed of dog, but way bigger than I am willing to handle in my house.
 
Can you go meet him? I think it's really important with an older dog to make sure he reacts well to you and your son.

We found our puppy online also and then went to meet him and his siblings to see which one we would want. We said we wanted Henry, but left him at the shelter to get neutered and shots. Then the boys worried all week that someone else would take him, so we had to go back the next week and get him to foster. We couldn't adopt him until he was neutered and had all his shots.
 
He's in a foster home. This shelter uses foster homes. They will bring the dog over for a visit or you can go to the foster home to visit. After you decide to use them, then you get them for a trial period for 2 weeks where you can decide if he does/doesn't work for your family. He's 11 months old, so he's not a puppy, but not older. Anyone have any ideas on this mixed breed?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top