Hee hee! I want to vote just to see the results so far, lol. I don't know if I'd go with what everyone votes for, or the opposite since the popular vote might indicate which name is also more popular in general!

LOL!
Just to share ... my daughter's name has not been duplicated in a class of hers yet. I named her Julia Renae. I wanted Juliana, but DH wouldn't go for it. I figured it'd give her more options when she was older if she didn't like her name, hee hee. (Julie, Julia, Ana ....)
I do think that the more "common" names from when we were younger are becoming the less common names now, kind of like a previous person posted about the Jessica phase. I actually considered the name Jessica for her too. And it would have fit her, too, lol.
What I think would be fun to go through your grade school class photos from 1st grade or so and see if you like a name from that group -- thinking of my class: Melissa, Katie, Bridget, Erin, Sarah ... see all of these pretty names!
I know either choice will be perfect for your little girl!