Butter for Shortening?

[nesser1981]

I'm out of shortening, has anyone used butter in place of it? For Cookies.

 

[BrattyMeg]

you can...it's 1:1 ratio but if your butter is salted, I"d leave out the salt in the recipe if it calls for any.

do you have applesauce? that's a good substitute too

 

[Jenn Barrette]

Yup it will work fine

 

[nesser1981]

Thanks girlies!

Nope, out of apple sauce. I have the little cups of pear sauce. LOL!

 

[BrattyMeg]

pear would probably work but for cookies I think I'd use the butter instead...cake would be good for the apple/pear sauce though! Make it really moist

 

[Darcy Baldwin]

The thing about butter is that it melts more than shortening, so your cookies might be a bit flatter and crisper than if you used shortening.

You can read more about the science behind it here.

 

[meganmecrazy]

95% of the time I use butter instead of shortening. But like Darcy said...they will probably come out flatter.

 

[Nathalie]

But cookies with butter taste sooo much better imho!

 

[Jenn Barrette]

I like to do half and half personally, good combination of taste and texture

 

[Stacey42]

I use butter for shorting nearly all the time.

 

[nesser1981]

They turned out good guys. Thanks.

They are suppose to be chewy, so maybe that's what the shortening helped. I don't know, it was the first time I'd tried the recipe, so it turned out good and we don't know the difference.