American Idol - Top 16 tally

[Paula]

Wow!! There were a few curveballs thrown into this week's show wasn't there?

Here's the tally:
~Julie~: 4
4noisyboys:
dana: 5
FlirtatiousBrat: 5
isaacsmom: 6
Jennifer: 5
jessica31876: 5
jorgies5: 5
Keely~B: 3
kresta: 4
LeeAndra:
Leila: 3
Mandy: 1
meganmecrazy: 4
Nettio: 5
nikkiARNGwife: 3
pam4gators: 4
Paula: 6
rachaelsscraps: 5
sarahbhb: 6
scrapmonkey: 3
scrapperjade: 2
sczos911: 6
tracyfish: 6

If there are any mistakes, please let me know!!

 

[jessica31876]

forgot again to watch. So who went home this week?

 

[Tracyfish]

Katelyn, Lily, Alex and Todrick

a couple of those were real shockers!

 

[Leila]

All I have to say is W.T.F??? :huh::glare:

 

[Paula]

Me too Leila! And poor Alex, he had me bawling my eyes out!

 

[Jennifer]

Not cool. :thumbdown:

 

[4noisyboys]

ok Leila...I put a WTH in another thread, but WTF is a lot more what I was feeling!

I hope someone picks Lily up right away and records something for her. She's so awesome. Alex needs a lot of experience, but OMG...when I close my eyes, he voice just gives me the chills. Love him. I'm so so sad tonight!

 

[Leila]

Yeah, I just wish I could have typed out the whole thing!

ITA on Lilly and Alex. They both deserved to stay a lot longer, especially Lilly.

 

[4noisyboys]

that's ok...i hear ya loud and clear!

 

[scrapmonkey]

I was semi-surprised about Alex - I thought he would make it, but had a feeling that if his performances didn't pick up and show a little more energy, he was going to go home next week. Too bad his song reminded me of the insurance commercial with the dog and his bone.
Lilly was a shock, big time. I'm sure she will get a deal - she's got too unique and sweet of a voice. I'd love to see her on the indie charts a la Sia or Imogen Heap, but she'll probably go a different route. :thumbdown: for her going home.

 

[BrattyMeg]

dohh i had katelyn in my picks and changed it last minute..boo to that haha

total shock on the guys for me...I don't think Alex deserved to go home