American Idol (spoilers)

N

nikkiARNGwife

New member
TONIGHT is why this new way of choosing the top 12 sucks! There were several tonight that deserve a spot even over some of the ones that already have a spot. KWIM? I just think this 12 was way better than either of the other two groups as a whole don't ya think?

I don't know all their names yet but I like the guy who did the different version of Delilah, the girl they brought back..Felicia maybe? Scott, Lil, Jorje (sp?) and it feels like I'm forgetting someone else I like tonight but my point is...only 3 get a spot and it's just not fair! Okay..vent over lol.

Yes..the wild card show but only 3 there too...I'm just not liking how they choose this season. at. all.
 
I want Scott, Ju'Not and Jorje. (or however you spell it)
All three gave me chills.
 
I was totally thinking the same thing. I do not like the way they are choosing the top 12 this year! I definitely want Scott to make it, but there are several others that really should make it through!
 
I totally agree with you, Nikki! The Top 12 isn't going to consist of the best 12, and that's just stupid.

There were at least 4 good people tonight who should make it through, and that's obviously not going to happen.
 
I agree! But I have a question. If they called that one girl back last minute, that means someone dropped out, right? Who was it? I can't figure it out. I am not loving this new format at all.
 
LilyAnne2112 said:
I agree! But I have a question. If they called that one girl back last minute, that means someone dropped out, right? Who was it? I can't figure it out. I am not loving this new format at all.
Click to expand...

Joanna was disqualified after making the top 36
 
I actually liked Von tonite! He started the show off well..I liked Ju'not, Scott, Lil Rounds, and Jorge Nunez...I can hope that 2 guys and Lil go thru..then hopefully the guy that doesn't make it will get thru in the wildcard.
 
Mandy said:
I want Scott, Ju'Not and Jorje. (or however you spell it)
All three gave me chills.
Click to expand...

Yes, yes, and yes. I love that song Scott sang, I've loved it since it came out in the 80s (yes, I'm old, shut up LOL). This is my top 3 for the night.

I missed last week because of my borked satellite dish, so I can't compare it to that.
 
ITA about last night being better than the prior weeks'. There were some talented pipes. I hope Lil and Scott go on for sure and hopefully Ju'Not. I actually tried voting this week - got through for Scott, but kept on getting a busy signal for Lil, so I think that's promising for her. I could not stand Alex or Nathaniel.
I'm very curious who they'll choose for the wild card round.
 
Well, we all know that Lil will make it through since they had her sing last. If you remember, Danny and Adam, respectively, sang last during their weeks and made it through. The three of them could easily make Top 5 since they are the 3 best singers in the competition.

Scott's nice and sweet and a pretty good singer, but are people going to vote for him because they genuinely like him or is he going to get the pity vote? They've never had anyone with a disability make it this far before. It will be interesting to see how America handles it.
 
I think Lil was best girl by a mile and will sail through. Maybe I need to see Scott behind the piano before mentally ousting him, but I thought Jorge totally outsang him. Ju'Not, too, really. I think Scott has a great story, but last night's performance was mediocre compared to other contenders throughout the competition.

And what about the "cute as a button" girl? I think she needs to get over herself. That expression has a lot to do with your personality and not just your looks...unlike the "you've got great legs" comments.
 
I agree. I REALLY want Jorge to go through. REALLY badly. I thought he did an excellent job last night.
 
Scott makes me feel so joyful. He's a doll. Ju'Not was awesome..Jorge was awesome..and I *think* Lil was awesome, but my ears stopped working a little because my eyes were fixated on her gigantic hootie-back (butt). Seriously..after her song was over, I looked at Jules and was like.."Did she do well?"..and he said.."Yeah, didn't you hear her?"..and I said.."I think all my senses were being consumed by the eyeballs and her big ole' butt."
 
Scott makes me feel so joyful. He's a doll. Ju'Not was awesome..Jorge was awesome..and I *think* Lil was awesome, but my ears stopped working a little because my eyes were fixated on her gigantic hootie-back (butt). Seriously..after her song was over, I looked at Jules and was like.."Did she do well?"..and he said.."Yeah, didn't you hear her?"..and I said.."I think all my senses were being consumed by the eyeballs and her big ole' butt."
Click to expand...

LMBO!! Me too!!! It was like a little shelf sitting back there..she could like sit knick-knacks and things up there! lol
 
I just don't think that vocally Scott is all that great. I certainly don't want to sound mean, but I wonder how much his disability is affecting people's perception of him. Do I think he's accomplished alot, yes - but his voice is just not that strong. I thought there were several others with much stronger voices and performances - Lil, Jorge, JuNot, Felicia.
 
*lol* I totally noticed, too! At first I thought it was a shadow, but it was definitely all Rounds!!

I'm surprised that Jeff didn't notice since he is all abt T & A, but he didn't say anything. If she'd been in a different color than black, I'm sure he would have been all over that. He's got a thing for Beyonce, and Lil definitely does B. one better when it comes to junk in the trunk. :)
 
I have to say the reason that I like Scott so much is that when he's singing he is good (admittedly not fantastic) and you can feel the song so much more, if that makes sense (I think Kara said that too - that you could feel the passion coming from him). I also think from watching Hollywood week that when he is behind the piano, he actually is a better singer than what he showed last night. I don't think he will make it all the way, but I think he will be one of those contestants that will get a deal, will write his own songs, and make a modest career out of it with a couple of top 100 songs along the way, kind of like Elliot Yamin has done. I like how he chose Bruce Hornsby, as I think that is the kind of artist niche he will fit into, you know, Adult Contemporary I think is what it's called. Regardless, Scott did better last night than most of the other contestants in the two weeks before - compared to last night's set I'll admit he wasn't as good as some of them.
Jorge seems to be a better singer, but maybe I was influenced by what he was singing - I couldn't stand it and I think that's why I haven't been rooting for him.
Just my 2 cents...
 
I'd like to know how they came up with the 3 different groups. Was it the luck of the draw or was it strategic somehow. Hmmm....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top