AI: So who do you LOVE?

J

jessica31876

New member
Im just curious who you love from Idol this season? I am loving Casey. He is adorable. So who is your favorite? Do you not have one yet?
 
You know, I'm just not wowed yet. Nobody's truly one me over enough to vote. I'm really leaning toward Crystal Bowersox though. There's just something about her.
 
I'm torn between the girls - I really like Crystal, Lilly and Siobhan, but I think Crystal needs to lose the harmonica going forward. I like Michelle's voice, but there's something about her overall I don't care for....
On the guys - judging from the voting, I'm probably one of the few that like John (a really good soul voice); but I also really like Michael and Andrew, even if they didn't perform super well this time.

At this stage, there's definitely no blowout performance in either group that says someone is going to be the next Idol.
 
For the guys...Casey, Andrew and Lee. Casey for more than just his voice ;)

and for the girls...Crystal, Lily and Didi (if I have their names right). I really like Siobhan too...she's got an interesting voice.

My boys all love Lily the best...but they are all adults and love that style of music...their second fave is Crystal and then Didi.
 
I really like Siobhan... I hate the way she dresses, but she's got a powerful, amazing voice.

One thing though that I don't really agree on, is that Simon says this is the girls year, that they have the best girls this season. Personally, I find all the girls a little blah. Nobody is amazing and I downright think a couple shouldn't have even made it to Hollywood, let alone into the Top 24 (Haeley - I cringe EVERY time she sings - I can't stand her pitchy/lispy singing).
 
I totally agree with you Jaedyn, some of them shouldn't have even made it to Hollywood like that Haley girl i cant stand her voice i cringe as well when she sings
 
I cringe when Haeley talks...she's annoying.

My faves right now are Casey :wub: and Lee...I thought Casey did the best last night between the two though..he just picked a great song and sang the melody..I think Lee should pick a better song next week..his voice is better than Caseys...but seriously..is no one else seeing the resemblence to a young Brad Pitt??

brad-pitt---legends-of-the-fall--c1.jpg


No? :)

That little guy Aaron can sing too...I see now why they put him through. He's young but he can sing.

I told DH last night as we were watching though that I think David Cook has ruined all future AI for me lol...he raised the bar too high and now it's hard to find anyone that can reach it kwim?
 
jae - i agree! the girls - no one brings anything original. guess my picks for the girls is crystal and didi. they just need to step it up and be different.
 
sczos911 said:
jae - i agree! the girls - no one brings anything original. guess my picks for the girls is crystal and didi. they just need to step it up and be different.
Click to expand...

I really like Crystal - but I agree with whoever said to lose the harmonica. And I really really like Didi - she has such a soulfull, jazzy voice. I like Lilly too. So I guess there are a few girls that might get my vote if I lived in the US, lol!
 
My faves (pretty much in order) are
GIRLS:
Crystal Bowersox
Lilly Scott
Didi Benami
Siobhan Magnus

GUYS:
Lee Dewyze
Michael Lynche
John Park
Andrew Garcia
 
Funny I was just telling my DH that this year is weird because there is no particular person that I'm really pulling for (I've never once voted but have watched all but seasons 1 and 3 from beginning to end). I'm hoping that by the time we get to the top 12 there will be someone that really stands out to me because I think it makes watching the show that much more fun.
 
I am really dissappointed in all of them this season, they seem to be singing all those slow songs. It has really started to bore me. Nobody really has "kicked it up a notch"
 
My Favorites
Girls:
Crystal
Katie
Didi

Boys:
Andrew
Lee
John


Watching AI & I just want to say I'm angry right now............

I really loved John and now I'm upset he went home. UGH!!!
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure I'm loving anyone so far. For some reason I'm having a really hard time getting into this season. I think I just loved Kris Allen so much last year that no one so far really compares. :D
 
Okay, I absolutely love Alex Lambert. And he is totally off of everyone else's radar. Yes, right now his stage presence sucks. But I'm a music person (music degree, lead worship, etc.) and I'm telling you, this kid has got mad talent. You just can't make up that kind of tone. He's incredible, and I'm really hoping other people start to see that soon, before he's voted off.
 
Am I the only one that doesn't get the obsession so many people have with Casey?!?!

I guess I'm totally opposite everyone else! lol! I didn't like Adam Lambert last year, and I don't get the whole Twilight thing either... am I an oddball?! lol!

I really like Andrew Garcia's voice... I'm not really a fan of any of the girls yet...
 
I am really liking Crystal the most right now. But, I bet she just wants to die doing those awful group numbers. I absolutely HATE those - there's just nothing cheesier IMO. Crystal doesn't fit the mold of your average AI contestant. And, I can just see her rolling her eyes at being made to do those group numbers. LOL!
 
I don't have any favorites yet...it could be because I was so invested in rooting for Kris last year. I'm hoping somebody will really stand out for me by top 12.
 
I had a dream about Casey last week. :o He's not one of my favorites though...I like Andrew, Didi and Crystal. I am SO glad Haeley got the boot this week! I couldn't stand her singing!
 
Last edited:
For the guys I really like Lee, Casey & Andrew and I'm also rooting for Alex Lambert a bit too. For the girls I'm liking Crystal and Lilly and was SO happy to see that Haeley girl go last night, dang was she annoying!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top