Team Jacob or Team Edward and why?? *possible spoilers

A

alansrock

Active member
So since I just finished I am curious were you Team Jacob...or Team Edward...or were you Team Edward and then went Team Jacob when Edward left...or were you Team Jacob and then realized you were Team Edward...or were you Team Edward all along and why???

I was Team Edward from the start. I feel I have an old soul and he is just too fascinating to me. Jacob seems immature and not the kind of guy I'd be interested in for anything other than fun. So for me it was Edward all the way. I mean he is EDWARD!!!!!
 
Last edited:
Team.. nobody

*ducks*

Sorry.. LOL. I watched the movie this week. I even went into it with an open mind and it just wasn't appealing so much to me :/ I think more than anything though I couldn't stand the actress that played bella - she seems like a big snot! She did this small annoying laugh thing during the movie.. ugh.

So yea. I'm sorry. Twilight isn't for me. Don't hate me ssd girlies!
 
I cant really pick one team ... I love them both. I like them for different reasons.

You cant help but be in love with Edward even if you dont like certain things about him (controlling etc) but he is so sweet and I love the old fashioned part of him. He truly loves her.
And even though Jacob wants Bella through most of the books and I dont like him for it, he did make her happy and bring out a different side of her.

In a perfect world they would be combined to be one person lol:p
 
Team Edward all the way! I've never disliked Jacob but I feel like Edward and Bella were destined for one another.
 
Totally Team Edward. How could anybody not totally fall in love with such an erotic love story??

Jacob is sweet and he was there for Bella when she needed him but, eh, he's just too much like a little (or big) brother to her in my eyes.
 
Team Edward... Unconditionally... No question about it...

I watched the movie for the first time on Tuesday, bought Twilight on Wednesday read it all, bought New Moon on Thursday, finished it last night... I had a HARD time getting through it ALL without Edward :( I was absolutely heart broken... Even though I KNEW all along he would come back all those chapters without him didn't do me well...

I don't really dispise Jacob, yet... :) I don't know what is in store for me... I'm on page like 97 on Eclipse and I can see that things are starting to change... So we will see... I just don't think I will ever be able to move on from Edward and those old fashoned ways he has... UGH! :) Makes me wish my hubby was Edward lol... He knows that, but I dont think he knows the extent of it hahah :)
 
I loved Jacob. I just thought he was so sweet and so much better for Bella. He loved her and didn't hurt her the way that Edward did. Its not that I didn't love Edward, cause I most certainly did and I do think its best the Bella & Edward ended up together, but really, I just loved Jacob (maybe more for myself? lol).
 
Kristin-

I have read all 4 books and saw the movie, but I feel the same way about the Bella chick, I thought the whole movie would have been SOOO much better if it was played by someone else. The books, in my opinion, were so much better than the movie.

But for what it's worth, I am probably team Jacob (the book Jacob, not the movie:) )

Kathy


KristinCB said:
Team.. nobody

*ducks*

Sorry.. LOL. I watched the movie this week. I even went into it with an open mind and it just wasn't appealing so much to me :/ I think more than anything though I couldn't stand the actress that played bella - she seems like a big snot! She did this small annoying laugh thing during the movie.. ugh.

So yea. I'm sorry. Twilight isn't for me. Don't hate me ssd girlies!
Click to expand...
 
kathy70 said:
Kristin-

I have read all 4 books and saw the movie, but I feel the same way about the Bella chick, I thought the whole movie would have been SOOO much better if it was played by someone else. The books, in my opinion, were so much better than the movie.

But for what it's worth, I am probably team Jacob (the book Jacob, not the movie:) )

Kathy
Click to expand...

I didnt even see this post!!! Kristen Steward just drives me insane!! Her sighs and her facial expression just killed me!! :)
 
emmasmommy said:
Totally Team Edward. How could anybody not totally fall in love with such an erotic love story??

Jacob is sweet and he was there for Bella when she needed him but, eh, he's just too much like a little (or big) brother to her in my eyes.
Click to expand...

Agree!

Team Edward hands down. He is an old soul and he fits me. Jacob is a kid to me

Oh and I can't stand movie Bella either but it's kristen
 
Last edited:
OK well Ive only read the first two so that being said I feel so bad for Jacob. It is in his blood to hate the "bloodsuckers" so I cant blame him for that and I think he really loves Bella. Maybe I will feel differently after reading the next book but after Edward left I just kinda question whether he REALLY loves her. Plus he kinda annoys me with the you cant do this...I wont let you at the end of the book when Bella says she was going to go see Jacob. So I guess Im Team Jacob for now. Ohhh and I think Bella is so much safer with Jacob then with Edward
 
jessica31876 said:
OK well Ive only read the first two so that being said I feel so bad for Jacob. It is in his blood to hate the "bloodsuckers" so I cant blame him for that and I think he really loves Bella. Maybe I will feel differently after reading the next book but after Edward left I just kinda question whether he REALLY loves her. Plus he kinda annoys me with the you cant do this...I wont let you at the end of the book when Bella says she was going to go see Jacob. So I guess Im Team Jacob for now. Ohhh and I think Bella is so much safer with Jacob then with Edward
Click to expand...

Those are a lot of the reasons I feel, too. Edward was very controlling. Jacob is safer.
 
KristinCB said:
Team.. nobody

*ducks*

Sorry.. LOL. I watched the movie this week. I even went into it with an open mind and it just wasn't appealing so much to me :/ I think more than anything though I couldn't stand the actress that played bella - she seems like a big snot! She did this small annoying laugh thing during the movie.. ugh.

So yea. I'm sorry. Twilight isn't for me. Don't hate me ssd girlies!
Click to expand...

Don't feel bad, Kristin! I'm so with you on this!!!!

I couldn't stand hearing about it, but decided to watch it anyway so I didn't maybe miss something- but I did! I don't see what all the hype's about... I almost fell asleep a couple of times while watching it!

(I also can't stand the actress playing Bella, and I don't think the actor playing Edward -if that's his name! lol!- is as hot as everyone says! :confused:

Ok, was Jacob the Native Amercian guy who's friends with Bella? Because I think he's better looking than Edward!!!! I bet I'll be razzed for that one, but it's just my taste! :p
 
Last edited:
The blinkie mrsmbm made me says it all!

Edward-Blinkie.gif
 
rachaelsscraps said:
Don't feel bad, Kristin! I'm so with you on this!!!!

I couldn't stand hearing about it, but decided to watch it anyway so I didn't maybe miss something- but I did! I don't see what all the hype's about... I almost fell asleep a couple of times while watching it!

(I also can't stand the actress playing Bella, and I don't think the actor playing Edward -if that's his name! lol!- is as hot as everyone says! :confused:

Ok, was Jacob the Indian guy who's friends with Bella? Because I think he's better looking than Edward!!!! I bet I'll be razzed for that one, but it's just my taste! :p
Click to expand...

Ok you don't have to like the books or the movie but you can't deny the hotness that is RPatz!

ROBERT-PATTINSON-GQ-SPREAD.jpg


:P:P:P:P:P
 
Well I guess I like different parts of each, but can I pick Team Emmett...serious hotness going on there and I always like the guys with a sense of humor :)
 
Oh and if I had to choose by looks from the movie I would totally choose James...sooo hot!! Once I saw him I was kinda disappointed they couldn't drag that scene out a bit LOL
 
See, I just don't think RP is that hot. I can actually smell him in his pictures LOL

I'm totally hot for James and Emmett. *drool*
 
I know why many women are crazy about him... but he's a little too "pretty boy" and James Dean wanna-be-at-the-same-time to me! lol! :p
 
Ummm, I don't think he is hot. Except when he's showin' some treasure trail.

I was totally Team Jacob because I thought

BELLA DID NOT DESERVE EDWARD!!!!
 
I'm with Kristin, not a big fan of Twilight at all. LOL

But I like Kristen Stewart, and RPattz is awesome (as Cedric Diggory LOL) but in all honesty....


I am TEAM EMMETT!!! (and if you read this, you'll know why)
 
joelsgirl said:
Ummm, I don't think he is hot. Except when he's showin' some treasure trail.

I was totally Team Jacob because I thought

BELLA DID NOT DESERVE EDWARD!!!!
Click to expand...

bwahahahahahahahaha!

OK, don't throw rotten tomatoes... I haven't read the books or seen the movie. I just have no interest in the story. Please don't kick me out of SSD! :p:blink:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2026 XenForo Ltd.
Back
Top